Skip to main content

Conducting a performance review

  • creating a performance improvement plan (PIP)

A performance review and PIP requires a structured and constructive approach. Remember, the goal of is to support the software engineer in improving their performance and contribution. Approach the process with a problem-solving mindset, maintain open lines of communication, and offer the necessary resources and support to help them succeed. As a human resources expert, I understand the importance of treating employees with respect and sensitivity, especially when dealing with sensitive situations like this. When providing feedback to an employee who is unable to be a productive contributor due to mental health issues, it is crucial to approach the situation with empathy and compassion. Remember, the goal of this conversation should be to support the employee, while also addressing the productivity concerns of the company. Approach the situation with empathy, maintain open lines of communication, and be willing to explore reasonable accommodations or alternative solutions before considering termination as a last resort.

Prepare for the review​

Collect data and evidence related to the employee's performance, including specific examples of missed deadlines, incomplete tasks, or low-quality work. Gather feedback from relevant stakeholders, such as team members or project managers, to gain a well-rounded perspective.

Schedule a meeting​

Arrange a private meeting with the software engineer to discuss their performance. Inform them in advance about the purpose of the meeting and allocate enough time for a thorough discussion.

Provide feedback​

Begin the performance review by objectively and specifically addressing the areas where the employee's productivity and contributions have fallen short. Focus on facts and avoid personal judgments or criticisms. Clearly communicate your expectations and how their performance is not meeting those expectations.

Seek their perspective​

Allow the employee to share their thoughts and reasons for their low productivity. This will help you understand if there are any underlying issues or challenges that may be impacting their performance. Encourage open and honest communication.

Collaboratively set goals​

Together with the software engineer, identify specific areas for improvement and set clear, measurable goals. Ensure that these goals are realistic, achievable, and aligned with the company's objectives. Make sure the employee understands the importance of meeting these goals and the consequences of not improving their performance.

Discuss support and resources​

Inquire if there are any resources or support the employee needs to enhance their skills or overcome any challenges they may be facing. This could include training opportunities, mentorship, additional tools or software, or access to relevant documentation. Offer assistance in accessing these resources and emphasize that you are committed to their success.

Develop a performance improvement plan (PIP)​

Create a written PIP that outlines the agreed-upon goals, timelines, and specific actions required for improvement. The plan should be clear, concise, and tailored to the employee's needs. Clearly state the consequences of not meeting the goals, including potential disciplinary actions or termination if necessary.

Regular check-ins and support​

Schedule regular check-in meetings to monitor the employee's progress and provide ongoing support. Offer guidance, feedback, and encouragement throughout the improvement period. Be available to address any questions or concerns they may have.

Document the performance review and PIP​

Keep a record of the performance review meeting, including key discussion points, agreed-upon goals, and the PIP. Both you and the employee should sign and acknowledge the document to ensure mutual understanding and accountability.

Follow up and evaluate progress​

Continuously assess the employee's progress against the goals outlined in the PIP. Provide feedback and recognition for improvements made. If the employee shows significant improvement, acknowledge their efforts and consider additional development opportunities to further enhance their skills.

Prepare for the conversation​

Before meeting with the employee, take the time to gather all the necessary information about their performance, including specific examples of how their productivity has been affected. This will help you provide clear and specific feedback during the conversation.

Choose a suitable time and place​

Find a private and comfortable space where you can have an uninterrupted conversation. Ensure there is enough time allocated for the discussion so that the employee doesn't feel rushed.

Express empathy​

Begin the conversation by acknowledging the employee's recent challenges and expressing empathy for what they have been going through. Let them know that you understand that they have been dealing with valid reasons for their absences, such as medical appointments and a death in the family. This will help establish a supportive and understanding tone from the start.

Focus on objective performance issues​

Shift the conversation towards the specific performance concerns that have arisen due to their prolonged absence or inability to be productive. Be clear about the impact their performance has had on the team or the company's goals. Use specific examples to illustrate your points and provide constructive feedback on areas where improvement is needed.

Offer support and resources​

After discussing the performance concerns, emphasize that you value the employee and want to support them in overcoming these challenges. Mention any available resources, such as an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) or counseling services, that can help them manage their mental health and improve their productivity.

Explore accommodation options​

Inquire if there are any reasonable accommodations that can be made to support the employee in their role. This could include flexible work hours, reduced workload, or modifications to their tasks. Discuss potential solutions together and be open to their suggestions.

Develop an improvement plan​

If both parties agree that termination is not the immediate solution, work together to create a performance improvement plan. Outline specific goals, timelines, and support mechanisms that will help the employee get back on track. This plan should be realistic, achievable, and focused on the employee's well-being.

Document the conversation​

It is essential to maintain accurate records of the discussion. Document the key points discussed, any agreed-upon accommodations or improvement plans, and the next steps. This documentation will serve as a reference point for future discussions and may be necessary for legal or HR purposes.