Skip to main content

Static or API

scenarios where switching from static JSON files to an API or microservice becomes a worthwhile investment​

Complexity Factors:​

  • Dynamic Data Requirements: If the data on your pages needs to change frequently without requiring a redeployment of your Angular application, an API is essential. Think of things like:
    • Real-time updates (e.g., stock prices, chat messages).
    • User-specific data (e.g., personalized recommendations, user profiles).
    • Data that is managed and updated by non-developers (e.g., content management systems).
  • Data Manipulation and Processing: When your application needs to perform complex filtering, sorting, aggregation, or other data transformations that are inefficient or impossible to do entirely on the client-side with static JSON, an API can handle this processing server-side.
  • Data Security and Access Control: If different users or roles need to see different subsets of data, or if the data contains sensitive information that shouldn't be exposed directly in static files, an API allows you to implement robust authentication and authorization mechanisms.1
  • Data Relationships and Integrity: When your data involves complex relationships between different entities, managing and maintaining the integrity of this data across multiple static JSON files can become cumbersome and error-prone. A database-backed API provides a structured way to handle these relationships.
  • Integration with Other Systems: If your application needs to interact with other services or data sources, an API acts as a central point of integration.2
  • Scalability and Performance: While static files can be performant for small amounts of data, as your application grows and needs to handle more concurrent users or larger datasets, serving static files can become a bottleneck. An API backed by a scalable database and server infrastructure can handle increased load more effectively.
  • Code Maintainability and Separation of Concerns: As your application logic around data fetching and manipulation grows, embedding it within your Angular application can lead to a less maintainable codebase.3 An API promotes a clear separation of concerns between the frontend (presentation) and the backend (data logic).4

File Size Factors:​

  • Large Initial Load Time: If your JSON data files become so large that they significantly increase the initial load time of your pages, impacting user experience, then fetching data on demand via an API can improve performance. Users only download the data they need for the current view.
  • Redundant Data: If the same data is being repeated across multiple JSON files, an API with a centralized database can eliminate this redundancy, reducing the overall size of your application and improving maintainability.
  • Bandwidth Consumption: For users on slow or metered connections, downloading large static JSON files can be costly and time-consuming. An API allows for more efficient data transfer, fetching only the necessary information.5 When Does It Become Worthwhile? It's a judgment call, but here are some general guidelines:
  • Early Stage (Small Scale): For very small applications with simple, infrequently changing data and a limited number of pages, sticking with static JSON can be a quick and easy way to get started. The overhead of setting up an API might not be justified.
  • Growing Complexity: As soon as you start encountering the complexity factors mentioned above (dynamic data, needing to manipulate data, security concerns, etc.), it's likely time to seriously consider moving to an API. Don't wait until the complexity becomes unmanageable.
  • Significant File Size Issues: If your JSON files are consistently exceeding a few megabytes per page and are noticeably impacting load times, an API with pagination and filtering capabilities will likely provide a better user experience.
  • Anticipating Future Needs: If you foresee your application needing any of the dynamic capabilities or facing scalability challenges in the future, it's often wise to invest in an API sooner rather than later. This can save you significant refactoring effort down the line.

In summary:​

Think about the nature of your data (static vs. dynamic), the complexity of your data interactions, the size of your data, and your future scalability needs. If your static JSON approach starts to feel like a constraint or a source of performance issues, or if you need more dynamic capabilities, then the investment in an API or microservice will likely be worthwhile in the long run. It will lead to a more maintainable, scalable, and performant application.