email-automation-services
We are now transitioning into the Digital Marketing & Growth phase. This is often where "Build Then Market" can truly outshine pure engineering firms by proving that the software isn't just a tool, but a revenue engine.
Since you are a boutique firm owner, these scenarios will test if the competitor is a "Set it and Forget it" agency or a "Data-Driven Growth" partner.
Scenario 5: Marketing Automation & Lifecycle Email (The "Retention" Audit)
- The Persona: "Claire," Director of Marketing for a high-end regional home services brand (e.g., luxury landscaping, interior design, or custom cabinetry) in the Tri-State area.
- The Goal: Claire has a solid list of 5,000+ past clients and leads, but they only email them manually once a month. She wants to automate the "Customer Journey"—from the moment someone downloads a guide to the post-purchase "Thank You" and referral request.
- Budget Anchor: $2k–$4k/month retainer or a $5k setup fee. She wants to see "Open Rates" and "Attributed Revenue."
The Outreach Script (Email / Contact Form)
Subject: Inquiry: Email Automation & Lead Nurture Strategy for [Company Name] "Hi, I’m the Marketing Director at [Company Name]. We have a growing list of leads and past customers, but we aren't doing a good job of staying top-of-mind. I’m looking for an agency that can help us move beyond basic newsletters. We need to set up automated drip campaigns for new leads, a re-engagement flow for old clients, and a system to track who actually converts from our emails. We currently use [Mailchimp/Klaviyo/HubSpot]. Do you handle the technical setup (segmentation/triggers) as well as the copywriting, or do we need to provide the content? Looking forward to hearing your approach."
The "Deep-Dive" Secret Shopper Questions (For the Phone/Zoom Call)
- The "Segmentation" Test (Data Intelligence):
- Question: "We have different types of customers—some are residential, some are commercial. How do you make sure they aren't all getting the same emails?"
- What to look for: Do they mention Conditional Logic, Tagging, or Dynamic Content? (If they just say "we make two lists," they are juniors).
- The "Deliverability" Test (Technical Marketing):
- Question: "I'm worried about our emails hitting the 'Promotions' tab or Spam. What’s your process for ensuring our technical setup (DKIM/SPF) is correct?"
- What to look for: This is a "Developer-as-Marketer" question. A pro will talk about Domain Authentication and Warm-up sequences.
- The "Attribution" Test (Analytics):
- Question: "How will I know if the email campaign actually resulted in a sale? Can we track a click all the way to a phone call or a contact form fill?"
- What to look for: Listen for UTM Parameters, Conversion Tracking, and Dashboard Reporting.
- The "Copywriting" Test (Value Prop):
- Question: "Our brand voice is very 'high-end yet personal.' How do you ensure the automated emails don't sound like a robot wrote them?"
- What to look for: Do they mention Brand Voice Guidelines or a "Human-in-the-loop" review process?
- The "A/B Testing" Test (Growth Mindset):
- Question: "What if a certain subject line isn't working? Do you guys proactively change things, or do we just wait for the month-end report?"
- What to look for: An agile firm will suggest Continuous Testing of headlines and CTAs.
How to Grade Them (Your Internal Research)
| Metric | Red Flag (The "Blast" Agency) | Green Flag (The "Lifecycle" Partner) |
|---|---|---|
| Tool Knowledge | "We only use Mailchimp." | "We recommend Klaviyo/HubSpot for its advanced triggers." |
| Strategy | "We’ll send 4 emails a month." | "We’ll map out a 90-day automated customer journey." |
| Technical | Ignores SPF/DKIM talk. | Immediately asks to audit your domain DNS records. |
| Pricing | Flat fee for "sending." | Retainer based on Performance & Optimization. |